Testing:
In order to test the cooling performance of the Hiyatek HY-CF-6160-1, it was installed under an ASUS F7KR-X1 laptop computer. This is a larger computer which features a 17" widescreen display and full size keyboard, and I would say it is pushing the limits of what this cooler can physically handle, despite the product page stating "fit to all size laptop". It hangs off in all directions, tips if not positioned just right, and the fans wind up positioned towards the rear edge of the laptop. A (non-functional) 14" laptop I have on hand fits on the HY-CF-6160-1 much better, and I see this model being more appropriate for up to 15" laptops.
That said, the ASUS F7KR-X1 is the laptop I have on hand, and it will be used for testing. CPUID's HWMonitor 1.10 was used to monitor the temperatures of both CPU cores, the GPU core, and the hard drive. The system was monitored three times, without the cooler in place, with the cooler in place and the fans set to a low speed, and with the cooler's fans set to high speed. In order to generate some heat, the laptop was used to execute 3DMark06 two times in a row, and upon exiting the final session the maximum temperatures were recorded. In between each of the three sets of tests the system was shutdown for about one hour in order to let it cool off.
The chart above provides the results which were obtained while maintaining an ambient temperature of 25C. As you can see there wasn't much impact no matter how fast the fans spun. Both CPU cores and the hard drive dropped by one degree, while the GPU temperature didn't change at all. Other coolers have been able to tame the heat from the F7KR-X1, but perhaps this is just another indication that this laptop is too big for this cooler.
Conclusion:
Earlier in the review I mentioned that I like coolers like this because they double as docking stations, and you would really have to look to the Hiyatek HY-CF-6160-1 to fill that role. While it may operate in near silence regardless of fan speed, you might as well just leave it turned off since it isn't really cooling anything.
Searching the web for a place to buy the Hiyatek CF-6160-1 Laptop Cooling Pad was unsuccessful. If I had to guess, I would place it somewhere around $20, as there are comparable models out there in this price range. While other units might do better at cooling, this one is nice thanks to its lightweight and compact design, integrated 3-port USB 2.0 hub, and the adjustable typing angle you can create to maximize your comfort.
Pros:
» Compact and lightweight
» Quiet
» Creates an adjustable, ergonomic typing angle
» Integrated 3-port USB 2.0 hub
» Built in power switch and speed controller for fans
» USB powered with included cable
Cons:
» Minimal cooling impact
» Not for larger laptops
Special thanks to Hiyatek for providing the Hiyatek CF-6160-1 Laptop Cooling Pad to Bigbruin.com for review!
Please drop by the Bigbruin.com Forum and feel free to post any comments or questions.
|
|
